When I last visited Sirmione in Italy I gained free access to a museum because I was an EU citizen.
When I last visited Budapest in Hungary I was able to ride the city trams free of charge because I was a Senior Citizen of the EU.
In all of my frequent visits to Europe I knew that if I needed medical treatment I could get it without my bank balance being raided.
I could also make phone calls on my mobile without the charges being ramped up.
I was able to cross from one country to another with no more bureacratic hindrance than crossing from England into Scotland.
When staying in hotels in my own country (UK) I've benefited from efficient and pleasant service from staff who were recruited from other EU countries.
When admitted to hospital I received superb attention from doctors, nurses, health care assistants, and cleaners, many of whom were from the EU (and beyond).
I eat vegetables that have been picked from fields (sometimes in freezing or wet conditions) by workers from other EU countries. Far from 'stealing our jobs' (we currently have low unemployment rates) they are doing work that many of those who are unemployed don't want to do.
The quality of our rivers, our coastal waters, and the air we breathe, the safety of our cars, and much else are controlled by EU regulations that we ourselves have helped to formulate.
Far from being a 'Vassal State' 'Shackled' to Brussels, and 'Dictated to by an unelected bureacracy', we have jointly participated in Europe's future with other elected leaders, and an elected parliament. We have been able to opt out of a single currency, and to opt out of the Schengen 'open borders' agreement.
We have benefited from cross-border policing, national security, medical and scientific co-operation and co-ordination.
We trade freely not only with millions of people on our doorstep, but with 70 other countries around the world via agreements made with the EU. So far, there are only provisional separate agreements with a dozen of them.
As for 'Unelected bureacrats', since when were Civil Servants ever elected, in any country?
And yet our nationalistic tub-thumping Brexiteering government expect us to replace all this with what? .. Turbo-boosted Optimism! WHY?! Because a slim majority of us voted for it after being fed dreams, aspirations, and lies instead of real facts. Some of those voters phone radio stations, and when asked to explain why, or what is it they could do outside the EU that they can't do now, they come up with garbage such as .. "I want to eat fish and chips out of newspaper again" (nothing to do with the EU), "I want to control our borders" (we already do), and "I want to buy curved bananas" (tabloid newpaper myth). Thankfully, nobody has yet said, "I want our money to return to £sd!" (Also nothing to do with the EU).
And now our new (undemocratically chosen) arm-waving blustering Prime Minister has a parliamentary majority of only ONE (and that's even counting the dubious support of Northern Ireland's DUP). There's only one solution now .. a General Election and an end to this madness.
Search This Blog
Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts
Showing posts with label EU. Show all posts
03 August 2019
Disunited Kingdom
Labels:
Brexit,
Brussels,
election,
EU,
Euro,
immigration,
Prime Minister,
Schengen
16 October 2018
BREXIT .. It's up to US
My earlier Blog was an attempt to lighten the mood. Now is the time to get a bit more serious.
Whether you voted to leave the EU or voted to remain, you
didn’t vote for the unmitigated chaos that we are now wading through, and neither
did you (no doubt with a few swivel-eyed exceptions) vote to be poorer, or to
be marched off the cliff by a group of fanatics telling you that you’ll enjoy
the drop and when you hit the water some of you will drown, but others will
swim on until they rock up on the sun-drenched beaches of an island called Our
Glorious Past.
The UK does not do referenda as a matter of course; we are a
representative democracy in which we elect Members of Parliament to represent
us to the best of their ability. But thanks to the efforts of Nigel Farage and
others of his ilk, former Prime Minister Cameron tried to stop his Party from haemorrhaging
votes to UKIP by promising us a referendum in the mistaken belief that the
country would vote to remain. All he achieved was to cause an acrimonious
division of roughly one half of the population against the other half. It is
Cameron who is to blame for the mess in which we now find ourselves.
Then along came Theresa May as the new leader of the
Conservatives, and thus Prime Minister. She demonstrated her soundness of
judgement by calling a completely unnecessary election (she had a working
majority, remember) in the belief she could increase her majority. The result
was that she lost her working majority and had to ‘bribe’ the Democratic
Unionist Party of Northern Ireland to prop her up in Parliament. As a result,
the Northern Irish bigots have her over a barrel.
The problem we have with our Parliament now is that there
are divisions all over the shop regarding how to proceed with Brexit, the worst
of which are within the governing Party. Even within the Prime Minister’s
Cabinet there are divisions between ‘Leavers’ and ‘Remainers’, and there are
further divisions even between the ‘Leavers’; some want a good deal with the
EU, others are happy with no deal.
The Labour Opposition also has its fair share of Brexiteers; the Party is torn
between supporting a deal brokered by the Prime Minister and opposing
everything she comes forward with in the hope of triggering a General Election
which they are fairly confident of winning. The two Parties which are
consistent in their desire to remain in the EU are the Liberal Democrats (not
enough of them to make a difference) and the Scottish Nationalists.
We can no longer rely upon Parliament to come to any
meaningful decision on how to proceed, which brings me to the so-called People’s Vote being called for by
increasing numbers of despairing people. They are shouted down by every Brexiteer
in the land uttering the wearingly familiar “We’ve already had a people’s vote
in 2016 and we voted to leave the EU. We don’t want a second referendum.” I
despair: are these people so thick that they cannot realise that what is being
asked for is not a second bite at the cherry, but a vote on the
DEAL that is finally served up to us? Clearly Parliamentary arithmetic
is so fluid that the only people who can accept or refuse the final deal are ..
US!
WE were given a
vote on the original proposition, and now, to have our say in how we implement it is not a denial of
democracy, it is an EXTENSION of democracy. It is Democracy Plus. After all,
from time to time we elect Parliament, and by extension, Government. Nobody
says that a decision we take on that should not be re-visited five years later.
Nothing is set in stone forever. Conditions change. New information becomes
available. People ‘fall off’ the electoral register when they reach the end of
life; others come on to the register when they reach voting age.
There is nothing wrong with the ‘People’s Vote’. Give us the
real facts, and give us the vote.
17 September 2018
Brexit for Dummies
A Brief History
About two years ago there was a referendum on whether we
should all eat a Full English Brexit or opt for the healthier Continental
option. Just over half the country voted in favour of the Full English Brexit
and ever since then we have been a Disunited Kingdom inhabited on the one hand
by ‘Brexiteers’ and on the other by ‘Remoaners’.
It was all started by a man called Nigel who was
uncomfortable with hearing foreign languages being spoken on the train and
yearned for the ‘good old days’ when farage balloons were flying over London
and we were busy telling the pesky Germans where to stick their bratwursts.
He started a political movement called UKIP which came to be
known as the Kippers (which, as you know, also feature as an option on Full
English Brexit menus). UKIP was so successful that eventually they represented
as much as 0.3% of the British House of Commons which threw the then Prime Minister “Call-me-Dave”
Cameron into a blind panic, believing that the Kippers were causing a stink by
stealing Conservative votes. So Dave went for discussions with the European
Onion to see if he could peel away some of the layers without causing tears at
bedtime. He returned waving a piece of paper, declaring “Peace in our time”.
Sorry, that was someone else, back in the good old days. But the effect was the
same; it wasn’t peace and he hadn’t persuaded anyone to make the Continental
option look more like the Full English. But he was confident that he had, and
so triggered the referendum which he knew he would win, which he didn’t.
The Kippers were more successful in gaining entry to the
European Parliament thanks to a different voting system, and they devoted their
time to frustrating proceedings, led by Nigel who (I felt in a rather
un-British way) proceeded to personally insult the people running the European
Onion, in particular the President of the Commission; Nigel told him he had the
appearance of a low-grade bank clerk and the charisma of a wet dishcloth (or
something along those lines) .. i.e., British diplomatic manners at their
finest.
Back in Britain, Nigel the Chief Kipper, failed to
get himself elected to the British Parliament in spite of having built up a
fanatically loyal fan base rather like the one ‘The Donald’ built in the USA.
In fact Nigel actually spoke at one of Donald’s rallies. They both have a lot
in common.
Where are we now?
As we approach the time when we must depart the shores of
the European Onion, there has been much talk about staying within the
supermarket. This is understandable because having been inside the supermarket
for 40 years we are still unsure about where they’ve put the custard powder
this week. I think it is wise to stay inside the supermarket until we find out,
but Prime Minister May has accepted that in order to exit the supermarket there
is a price to pay on exit (which is known as the ‘Checkout’). She has come up
with a plan known as the Checkers Plan allowing us to go past the checkers
without too much fuss, and be taken home in a big red bus stuffed with extra
money for the NHS.
Nigel wants nothing to do with the supermarket because it’s
full of nasty foreign stuff, and you can never find the custard powder or, come
to think of it, the Marmite. He wants British Aisles. He also wants less
freedom of movement (though to my mind, you couldn’t have much less, what with
all those shopping trolleys). Now the one consistent thing about the
supermarket is that the fruit and vegetable section is always near the entrance
and it tends not to move about too much, but even here the Kippers are
complaining that there’s a preponderance of Brussels, and moreover the leeks
are being seen to by Polish plumbers. And if you find yourself in front a large
beetroot that is, as often as not, just Nigel getting very, very angry.
Now the ‘Three Brexiteers’, Bonkers Boris Johnson, Evil
Doctor Fox, and the Honourable Member for the 18th Century, Jacob
Rees Smug, are telling us that life outside both the supermarket and something
called the Custard Union is going to be a bowl of cherries, because the Germans
are still going to want to sell us their big Aldi cars (and even the Lidl
ones), the French will still want to sell us their wine, and the Dutch will
still want to sell us their cheese for so long as it takes for us to find the
flavour.
The Custard Union is something that causes much
consternation because it raises the subject of some Celtic border or other,
possibly the Cornish Border? (At least a ‘hard’ border here would deal with
those pirates of Penzance). But I digress; I am advised that we are concerned
here with the border between Northern Ireland and the Irish Republic, across
which there is much agricultural trade, and I’m assuming this is the reason for
concern about a ‘hard’ border jeopardising the ‘Good Friday Peas Agreement’.
So, all in all, this is turning out to be a bit of a Dog’s Brexit,
but I hope I’ve helped to throw some light on the subject, so you can vote
sensibly when we have a referendum on the referendum, or possibly a General
Election producing a Labour Government which will put the great British sausage
into Public Ownership. Pass the custard mustard.
Lionel Beck
September 2018
29 November 2016
The Insane Politics of 2016
A Year Best Forgotten?
If only it were that simple. We could try to forget, but the
downside would be that much of the insanity would just carry on unchecked. We
owe it to ourselves and to those who follow us to keep the year’s events in
mind, think about them, and endeavour to make 2017 a little less like more of
the same.
It was a year of political upheavals, which could be
variously described as surprising, scary, unpleasant, incredible, and
(for some people with whom I have little understanding) actually exciting.
The values of our democratic
social & liberal society in Britain, Europe and the USA were severely
strained by an upsurge of extremist politics from both ends of the political spectrum.
Forgive this slight digression, but on the matter of the political spectrum, I don’t like the simplistic view of right and left being represented as a straight line with Socialists and Communists at one end, and Nationalists and Fascists at the other.In practice, this “straight” line is part of a circle’s circumference; Left & Right bend round in each direction becoming more extreme in each direction, resulting in completion of the circle. Where Left & Right join, we find that the two political credos are almost indistinguishable from each other. These extreme “ends” have things in common: a tendency towards dictatorship, totalitarianism, populism, racism, Media control, loss of individual liberty and the denial of human rights. (Think Joseph Stalin & Adolph Hitler. Think Fidel Castro & General Pinochet. In both pairings, they had so much in common, didn’t they?) This is what I mean ..
The European Union
![]() |
| Nigel Farage |
UKIP’s principal message was that we should “take back control”. That meant taking
back control of our borders and clamping down on immigration, and taking back
control of the sovereignty of Parliament, so that instead of being bound by
common laws dreamed up in Brussels by unelected bureaucrats (some of whom were
of course British) to be rubber-stamped by an ineffectual European Parliament,
we would “make our own laws”. There
was merit in some of the arguments, but then on the other hand some very useful
Europe-wide laws had come out of the EU, e.g., on working time, working
conditions, air and water quality, coastal waters quality, food labelling,
measures dealing with climate change, common access to health care, freedom of
travel, freedom to find work, and so on.
Free movement of people was a cornerstone of the EU credo,
which gave us all huge advantages in terms of being able to find work in any
European country, and being able travel freely and without hindrance on
holidays. On the downside – hugely exploited by UKIP and others – there was an
uncontrollable influx of immigrants, some of whom were very useful to us
(especially scientists, nurses, doctors, engineers, etc.) but many who were not
(unskilled, unemployed, receivers of benefits etc.) This latter group fuelled a
feeling of resentment among much of the UK population, encouraged by Farage’s
gratuitous comments about hearing foreign languages being spoken on trains
being unpleasant.
Unfortunately successive UK governments (in particular
Labour ones) had until recently stuck to an ideological belief system that
refused to recognise that immigration could ever
be a problem and actively encouraged hundreds of thousands of people to come
into the country without regard to their skills, their ability to seek work, or
even their ability to speak the language. Discussion of any social problems was
deemed to be “racist” and was shut down before it could gain traction.
In my opinion, the UK government should have had the courage
to stand up to the EU and take whatever measures were necessary in the national
interest. (Other countries seemed to have no qualms about bending the rules in
the national interest.) I believe the EU would have huffed and puffed and even tried
legal action, but it wouldn’t have
mattered. They would have caved in to our demands in the interest of
maintaining the EU as an ongoing entity.
But no, UKIP were stirring up hatred for the EU, Nigel
Farage was insulting people right, left and centre in the European Parliament,
and they were putting the wind up the Conservatives, especially when at the
last elections for the European Parliament they managed to send a large
contingent of UKIP MEPs to Brussels.
![]() |
| David Cameron |
The downright lies and pure fantasy that rained down upon us
from both the Remain and Leave campaigns swamped anything
resembling truly informative dialogue and we were standing up to our knees in
stinking controversy. Both sides were taking us all for fools. None of them
wanted to ‘confuse us with the facts’.
We had a binary choice, IN or OUT. The appeal to naked
nationalism by UKIP and the renegade Tories known as “Brexiteers” had more
effect than any positive arguments in favour of European co-operation, free
trade, and partnership, and the country voted NO to the EU. But .. only just, and the closeness of
the vote meant that bad feeling from one half of the population against the
other was rife, and even families were divided (mine included). Paradoxically, whilst
I voted to remain in the EU I would have been much happier if the vote to leave had been overwhelming and beyond
argument. 52% / 48% is not a good place to be.
![]() |
| Theresa May |
Hate Crimes
The worst aspect of the EU referendum campaign and its
result was the subsequent manifestation of something in the British character
that, frankly, some of us would prefer to deny exists, namely hate
and intolerance. I suppose there has
always been plenty of that around but the unwritten rules of society managed to
keep it well under wraps until the Internet, and Social Media, provided a ready
outlet for sociopaths, racists, anti-semites and various other varieties of
swamp life.
![]() |
| The late Jo Cox |
What have we become? It is totally insane.
Party Fortunes
The Labour Party
![]() |
| Ed Miliband |
![]() |
| Nick Clegg |
![]() |
| Jeremy Corbyn |
The result was that most of the Parliamentary Party vowed
not to work with him, whilst in contrast the support of the Party membership
outside of Parliament were placing him on a huge pedestal that might as well
have had a brass plaque attached with the somewhat appropriate initials .. JC.
By the time we had entered the insane year of 2016 JC was
being subjected to parliamentary pressure to resign, and a couple of Labour MPs
challenged him to another leadership contest. Again this meant another vote by
the Party Membership outside Parliament, and again the membership defied the
Parliamentary Labour Party and elected him for a second time. Even the Labour
Party in Parliament was not stupid enough to resist him again. Most of the “big
beasts” disappeared from the Shadow Cabinet and were replaced by people nobody
had ever heard of. Tony Blair’s social democratic “New Labour” had reverted to pure
socialism.
The Liberal Democrats
This Party, which has honourable social reforming roots
going back to William Gladstone and David Lloyd-George, had been reduced to 6
MPs at the end of World War II, (when
Labour won a landslide victory) and it then spent the rest of the 20th
century and the early part of this century slowly building up its popularity
again, to the point where it could boast more than 60 MPs. This put them in a
powerful position when, at the 2010 General Election, no single Party got
sufficient votes to form a government with a working majority. The outgoing
Labour Prime Minister Gordon Brown made half-hearted attempts to form a
coalition with the Liberal Democrats but the arithmetic didn’t really add up.
On the other hand if the Conservatives could form such a coalition the figures would add up. And so the
Conservative-Liberal Democrat Coalition Government came into being in 2010. We
were in middle of a major financial crisis and some kind of stable government
was urgently required.
The Coalition achieved some notable successes, namely
bringing back the nation’s finances under control, increasing cash for
education, increasing nursery places for pre-school children and assistance for
mothers, and most significantly raising the personal tax allowance which helped
the middle and low earners.
The Liberal Democrats were a driving force behind
many of the reforms of that Coalition, but their leader Nick Clegg had made one
huge mistake leading up to the 2010 General Election: he had campaigned
vociferously against University tuition fees and vowed to abolish them. No
doubt he didn’t expect to be in government when he made that commitment, but on
that basis he garnered a huge following. So, when in government his commitment was swallowed by the inevitable gaping
hole of coalition compromises, and tuition fees were increased rather than
abolished, the Liberal Democrats credibility and popularity stalled and
plummeted to earth in an uncontrollable spin.
Consequently the 2015 General
Election saw their MPs reduced to a miserable EIGHT. They were almost back to 1945! Their place as a Third Party
force to be reckoned with was taken over by about 50 Scottish Nationalists MPs
(who, by the way, virtually wiped out the Scottish Labour Party).
![]() |
| Tim Farron |
![]() |
| Norman Lamb |
The Conservative Party
There is very little to add about the Party now in
government, except to say that they are now faced with delivering the “Brexit”
that Britain voted for, using a plan that is either non-existent, or if it does
exist is not being shared with the rest of us.
(I say “Britain”, but interestingly most of Scotland voted
to remain,
thus providing even more opportunity for constitutional crisis. Paradoxically,
although Scotland had voted to remain part of the UK a couple of years ago, the
Nationalists who had complained about being ruled by a distant London are
apparently content to be ruled by an even more distant Brussels!)
UKIP
In 2015, this Party, under Farage’s dynamic leadership,
started sucking up millions of votes (many of them from Labour strongholds) but
because of the injustices of Britain’s “first past the post” system, the votes,
being spread around many constituencies up and down the land, only one MP was elected. They did much
better at the European Parliament elections because they are run on a
proportional representation system.
Although they produced a manifesto for government, their
over-arching reason for existence was to get Britain out of the EU, and in this
they succeeded. Ever since the referendum people have been understandably
asking, “What is UKIP for now?”
![]() |
| Paul Nuttall |
Meanwhile, in the USA ...
As President Barak Obama (Democrat) limped towards the end
of his second term, no doubt exhausted by continual criticism and sometimes racist abuse by Republicans about his inability to achieve
anything. This was high hypocrisy since the Republican Party had control of
both Houses of Congress and thus went out of its way to block anything the
President tried to do.
![]() |
| Donald Trump |
![]() |
| Hillary Clinton |
![]() |
| Bernie Sanders |
I’d always thought the term “American Socialist” was an
oxymoron, but I was wrong. Bernie Sanders started accumulating mass support,
similar in some ways to what Jeremy Corbyn had done in the UK. Nevertheless, it
was not enough to stop Hillary Clinton being adopted as Candidate for
President. She was a flawed candidate, not only representing the East
Coast/West Coast liberal establishment, but also mired in controversy over the
use of a private email server, allegedly putting national security at risk. The
Republicans, against all odds, also settled on a flawed candidate, i.e., Donald
Trump, who set about insulting and abusing women, the disabled, Mexicans,
Muslims, and of course Hillary Clinton (“Crooked
Hillary”. “Lock her up.” ) At one rally he also encouraged his supporters
to deal with a protester by punching him in the face.
Trump’s businesses were many and varied, as were his
bankruptcies, debts and tax evasion schemes. During the campaign a video
recording was unearthed in which we watched and heard him boasting to a TV
producer that he could grope women in the genital area and get away with it. I
think his actual words were “Grab them by the Pussy”. Future presidential
material??
Considering the huge size and population of the USA it was
somewhat surprising to those of us living on this side of the pond that these
two people were the best they could come up with to be leader of the “free
world”.
Against all odds Trump actually became President-Elect, and
just as the “Brexit” phenomenon in Britain produced all sorts of swamp life, a
lot of Americans started getting nasty and abusive with immigrants. Trump claimed
he stood for the forgotten unemployed, and the working poor, neglecting to
mention that he himself (living in gilded opulence) was a product of, and a
beneficiary of the Corporate world of
global capitalism that was mainly responsible for the existence of those
forgotten poor in the first place.
Having spent the entire campaign that was calculated to cause serious divisions throughout American society, on finally becoming President-Elect, Trump announced, in all seriousness, that he intended to unite the country.
They sucked it all up, and yelled “Make
America Great Again”. (By the way, when did America stop being “great”, and
what is meant by “great”? Nobody seems to know.)
![]() |
| Self-appointed champions of Blue-collar Workers |
All great populist stuff, but totally insane (and
dangerous).
Worse still, similar stuff has been stirring in Europe, with
far-right Parties in the ascendant in Holland, France, Germany, Austria,
Hungary and Italy – all exacerbated by waves of Middle Eastern and North African
immigrants fleeing civil wars and/or religious persecution, seeking refuge in a
Europe starting to collapse under the weight of alien social customs
and consequent widespread resentment.
All deeply troubling.
I’m at the fag-end of my life, and I could perhaps say I
don’t give a flying f*ck, but I worry about the future my grandson will inherit. So should you.
If this isn’t the time for Liberals to stand up for liberal
values, democracy and human decency, I don’t know when is!
©Lionel Beck - 2016
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)














